In "More of the Same", Father Time instructs Baby New Year to play and he sits on Starfire, pounds Cyborg's head and puts Beast Boy in his mouth. Raven then uses her soul-self to lift the baby off Starfire and creates a hand to spank him, scolding him to respect his elders. Baby New Year begins crying and flies off, leaving Father Time alone.
Baby New Year is a gigantic baby. He has flaming, orange hair and a little top hat with a red stripe. He is naked, except for a diaper that is pinned on with a safety pin. He still has a lot of baby fat which makes his wrists and arms really chubby. He has a bright yellow sash that has "Happy New Year," written in orange letters.
- More of the Same (debut; only appearance)